More
Log inCreate free accountJoin freeBuild a deck

How to grade and sell One Piece cards

Grading means sending a card to a company like PSA, CGC or TAG, which rates its condition from 1 to 10 and seals it in a labeled case; on November 12, 2026 the cheapest listed tiers were $20 at CGC (Economy), $39.95 at TAG (Base, 5-card minimum) and $39.99 at PSA (Value) per card. It only pays when the graded price beats the raw price by more than the fee and shipping, so check that first.

Last checked November 12, 2026 against PSA, CGC and TAG's own pricing and grading pages, and eBay's fee pagePublished November 8, 2026By the TCGenius team

On this page
  1. The grading scale
  2. PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC and TAG: how the scales differ
  3. Pop reports, and the gap between a 9 and a 10
  4. What grading costs
  5. Is grading worth it? Do the maths first
  6. How to send a card for grading
  7. How to sell One Piece cards
  8. Do it with TCGenius
  9. Questions people ask
  10. Sources

The grading scale

PSA's grading standards run from 1 to 10. The grade looks at four things: centering, corners, edges and surface.

GradePSA nameCentering allowed on the front
10Gem MintAbout 55/45 or better (75/25 on the back)
9Mint60/40 or better
8Near Mint–Mint65/35 or better
7Near Mint70/30 or better
6Excellent–Mint80/20 or better
5Excellent85/15 or better
4 to 1Very Good–Excellent to PoorWider, with more visible wear

"55/45" means the wider border may be up to 55% of the two borders added together. Full-art parallels have thin borders, so look closely at centering before you send one.

PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC and TAG: how the scales differ

Five companies grade most trading cards. They all use a 10-point scale, but the top of the scale is not the same thing at each.

  • PSA. One grade from 1 to 10, no subgrades. A PSA 10 is Gem Mint, and it is the grade most sold-price comparisons are quoted in.
  • BGS (Beckett). Four subgrades printed on the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. A 9.5 is Gem Mint and a 10 is Pristine. A 10 with all four subgrades at 10 gets Beckett's Black Label.
  • CGC. Has two 10s. Gem Mint 10 allows centering of about 55/45 on the front; Pristine 10 is above it and needs 50/50 centering and a card that looks flawless to the naked eye.
  • SGC. A 10-point scale in a black-bordered holder collectors call the tuxedo. It is a common choice for vintage cards.
  • TAG. Grades from machine imaging. Every card gets a 1 to 10 grade and a public report that maps its defects, and from the Standard tier up a score out of 1,000.

So "a 10" needs the company's name in front of it. A BGS 9.5 and a PSA 10 are both called Gem Mint, and a CGC Pristine 10 or a BGS Black Label is rarer than either. When you compare prices, compare the same company and the same grade.

Pop reports, and the gap between a 9 and a 10

A pop report (population report) is a grader's public count of how many copies of a card it has graded at each grade. PSA's is free at psacard.com/pop.

It matters because a grade is only scarce if few copies have it. If most of the copies sent in come back as 10s, a 10 is common and sells for little more than a 9. If only a small share do, because the set was printed off-centre or the foil scratches easily, the 10 is the prize and can sell for several times a 9.

Two cautions. The count only goes up: cards that are cracked out of their cases and sent in again are counted twice. And a low count on a new card usually just means few have been graded yet, not that the card is rare.

What grading costs

Prices per card, read from each company's own page on November 12, 2026:

CompanyTierPrice per cardNotes
CGC CardsEconomy$20.00Cards worth up to $1,000. Bulk is $17 a card with a 25-card minimum; Standard is $55.
TAGBase$39.955-card minimum. Value is $29.95 a card with a 10-card minimum.
PSAValue$39.99Cards insured up to $500. Estimated 90 to 100 business days.
PSAStandard$59.99Insured up to $1,000. Estimated 70 to 80 business days.
PSAPriority$79.99Insured up to $1,500. Estimated 50 to 60 business days.

PSA's faster tiers that day were Express ($199), Super Express ($349) and Premier ($599, insured up to $10,000). Sources: PSA, CGC, TAG. Shipping both ways and insurance are extra, turnaround times are the companies' own estimates, and prices change, so check the grader's page before you send anything. We don't quote a Beckett or SGC fee because we couldn't read their price pages that day.

Is grading worth it? Do the maths first

Work it out before you pay. You need three sold prices for your exact card, called comps: a raw (ungraded) copy, a PSA 9 and a PSA 10. Our One Piece prices give the raw one; for graded copies, look at recent sold listings for that card in that grade.

  1. Add up the cost. The grading fee, plus tracked and insured shipping there and back. At PSA's Value tier the fee is $39.99 a card (read November 12, 2026). Shipping depends on how many cards share the box, so use your own figure; call it S.
  2. Take the cost off each graded price. Net at a 10 = the PSA 10 price − $39.99 − S. Net at a 9 = the PSA 9 price − $39.99 − S. If you plan to sell, take the selling fee off too.
  3. Compare both with the raw price. If only the 10 beats the raw price, you are betting on a 10. If the 9 beats it too, grading pays either way.
  4. Be honest about the grade. Look at centering, corners, edges and surface under a bright light. Most cards straight from a pack are not 10s.

Our is it worth grading? calculator does this sum for you: pick the card, type the two graded prices you found, and it shows the profit at a 10, at a 9, and the chance of a 10 you would need to break even.

In letters: grading pays when (graded price − fee − shipping) is more than the raw price. With the $39.99 fee alone, before any shipping, a 9 has to sell for at least $39.99 more than a raw copy just to break even.

A rule of thumb that saves money: if the raw price is less than the grading fee, don't grade the card unless it means something to you. This is arithmetic, not a forecast: nobody can promise the grade or what the slab will sell for.

Check the gap between a 9 and a 10 for your card before you send it. On many modern cards a 9 sells for close to the raw price and nearly all of the extra value sits in the 10.

How to send a card for grading

  1. Choose the company and service tier that fits the card's value.
  2. Put the card in a fresh penny sleeve and a semi-rigid holder. PSA's shipping guide asks for exactly that, and says not to use top loaders or tape. Our storage guide explains the holders.
  3. Fill in the online form with each card's name, number, version and declared value.
  4. Pack the cards between stiff boards in a small box so they can't bend or move.
  5. Ship with tracking and insurance, and keep the receipt.
  6. Wait for the stated turnaround, then check your grades online before the cards come back.

Graded cards can't be played at Bandai events. The Tournament Rules Manual forbids "graded/'slabbed'" cards, so grade the copy you collect, not the one you play.

How to sell One Piece cards

  1. Sort first. Pull out Leaders, Super Rares, Secret Rares, Treasure Rares, parallels and Specials. The rest usually sells as bulk.
  2. Price from sold listings, not from asking prices. Our price tracker shows the market price for each version.
  3. Pick where to sell. The table compares the usual places.
  4. Photograph the actual card, front and back, in good light. Show any wear honestly.
  5. Ship safely: penny sleeve, top loader, and tracking for anything valuable.
WhereGood forTrade-off
Local game storeCash or store credit the same dayPays below market, because the store must resell the card
eBayReaching the most buyersA fee for trading cards of 13.25% up to $7,500, and 2.35% on the part above
Card marketplaces like TCGplayerSelling many singlesSeller fees and shipping on every order

Do it with TCGenius

Questions people ask

How much does it cost to grade a One Piece card?

On November 12, 2026 the cheapest listed tiers were $20 per card at CGC (Economy), $39.95 at TAG (Base, 5-card minimum) and $39.99 at PSA (Value); PSA's Standard tier was $59.99. Shipping is extra.

What is a pop report?

A population report is a grader's public count of how many copies of a card it has graded at each grade. When few copies have the top grade, that grade usually sells for much more than the grade below it.

Can you grade One Piece cards with PSA?

Yes. PSA, CGC and TAG all grade trading cards, using a 1 to 10 scale.

Is it worth grading One Piece cards?

Only when the graded price for the grade you expect, minus the fee, shipping and selling fees, is clearly higher than the raw price. That usually means valuable parallels in top condition.

What does a PSA 10 need?

About 55/45 centering or better on the front, and clean corners, edges and surface.

Can I play graded cards at One Piece events?

No. Bandai's Tournament Rules Manual forbids graded or slabbed cards.

Where is the best place to sell One Piece cards?

It depends on speed and price. A local store pays fastest but below market; eBay and card marketplaces reach more buyers but charge fees, like eBay's 13.25% on trading cards.

Sources

  1. PSA Grading Standards, psacard.com (read November 8, 2026)
  2. PSA trading card grading prices, psacard.com (read November 12, 2026)
  3. PSA Shipping Guide: how to package a submission, psacard.com (read November 12, 2026)
  4. PSA Population Report, psacard.com
  5. CGC Cards services and fees, cgccards.com (read November 12, 2026)
  6. CGC Cards grading scale, cgccards.com (read November 12, 2026)
  7. TAG Grading pricing, taggrading.com (read November 12, 2026)
  8. Beckett Grading Services (BGS), beckett.com
  9. SGC card grading, gosgc.com
  10. eBay selling fees help page (trading cards: 13.25% up to $7,500, 2.35% above)
  11. One Piece Card Game Tournament Rules Manual, last updated October 17, 2025

Rules and dates change. When a card or an official document says something different from this page, the official wording wins; tell us and we will fix the page.

Keep reading

TCGenius is an independent fan site. We are not affiliated with or endorsed by The Pokémon Company, Nintendo, Konami, Bandai, Wizards of the Coast, Hasbro, Riot Games, Disney or Ravensburger. Game names and card images belong to their owners.

The weekly meta report, by email every FridayWhich decks rose and fell in Pokémon and One Piece top 8s, what the winning lists changed, and the week's ban list and set news. One email a week; every one has an unsubscribe link.
We use your email only for this. See the Privacy Policy.
Share: XRedditFacebook