MTG deck rater: grade and analyze your Magic deck
The TCGenius MTG deck rater grades a Magic: The Gathering deck out of 100. For Standard, Pioneer, Modern, Legacy, Vintage and Pauper it finds the recent Magic Online top-8 lists that share the most spells with yours and checks the core cards those lists play; it also checks lands, mana curve, interaction, colors and the sideboard. Commander decks are checked against a common deck-building template. It's free.
75,076 cards · 84,975 tracked prices · 4,587 tournament decklists · updated every night
What problem it solves
A deck can be legal and still miss what the winning versions of it play: the right land count, enough answers, or the one card every list runs. Comparing by hand means reading dozens of decklists.
The rater does the comparison. It reads the official Magic Online results from the last 45 days, finds the lists most like yours, and tells you which of their core cards you're missing and where your lands, curve and interaction sit next to theirs.
How it works
- Open the Magic builder, pick the format, and build, paste or load a deck (you can start from a recent winning list).
- Press Grade. An illegal deck is graded too, capped at 40, with the problems listed.
- Half the grade is how many of the core cards (cards in at least 60% of the closest lists) you play; half is the structure checks. With too few similar lists, the whole grade is structure.
- Read each check: your number, the range the recent lists use, and what to change.
- Ask Genny to explain the grade or fix the weakest part.
What you get free and on paid plans
Free
$0, no card needed
- The grade, every check and the missing core cards, no account needed
- Test hands with opening-hand odds
- 1 Genny question a day with a free account
Pro
$19.99 a month or $179 a year · available now
- A big monthly Genny allowance on her strongest model to work through the changes
Prices and limits come from the same settings the app uses. Compare every plan.
Which games
- Magic: The Gathering: Standard, Pioneer, Modern, Legacy, Vintage and Pauper are compared with Magic Online Challenge, Showcase and qualifier top-8 lists from the last 45 days. Commander has no such results, so it gets structure checks against a common template, its color identity and its Game Changers count.
Questions
How is a Magic deck graded?
Out of 100. Half compares your deck with the recent Magic Online top-8 lists most like it: how many of their core cards you play. Half checks lands, mana curve, interaction, mana for your colors and the sideboard against the range those lists use.
Where do the winning decklists come from?
From the official Magic Online results Wizards of the Coast publishes: the top 8 of Challenges, Showcases and qualifiers, last 45 days. They're counted as a share of top-8 lists, never as a win rate.
Can it rate a Commander deck?
Yes. Magic Online doesn't publish Commander tournament results, so Commander decks are checked for lands, ramp, card draw, removal, board wipes and mana curve against a common deck-building template, plus the color identity rule.
What does a grade of 40 mean?
An illegal deck can't score above 40. The rater lists exactly what's not legal so you can fix it first.
Is the MTG deck rater free?
Yes, with no account needed.
More for Magic: The Gathering
Magic cards and prices · Ban list · Tournament decks · How to play
Related services
Last updated November 9, 2026. Spot something wrong? Tell us at hello@tcgenius.gg.