Where to sell Magic cards: every option, with the fees
You can sell Magic cards at a local card shop or buylist (cash today, no fees, a lower price), on eBay (the most buyers, 13.25% of the sale plus $0.30), on TCGplayer (a huge singles market, 10.75% commission plus a transaction fee), on Whatnot (live selling), in Facebook groups, Discord servers and at card shows (no fee, less protection). Fees are quoted from each site's own page, read November 8, 2026. Before any of that, find out what each card is worth: every Magic card on TCGenius has a free page with its market price.
First, what are they worth?
Sell nothing until you know the market price of each card for its exact printing and condition. That number is what the card has recently sold for; a shop will offer less, a private buyer may pay about that, and a marketplace takes a fee from it. TCGenius shows it free for every Magic card we track, with a chart so you can see where it's heading.
Every place to sell Magic cards, compared
| Where | What it's good at | What to weigh | Who it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local card shop or buylist | Cash or store credit today, no shipping, no fees; the quickest way to move bulk Magic cards | A buylist pays a share of market that isn't published and varies by shop; expect well under the online price | Bulk, and anyone who wants it gone today |
| eBayFee source | The most buyers anywhere; auctions for cards that are hard to price; Standard Envelope for cheap cards; Authenticity Guarantee on expensive ones | 13.25% of the total sale (item, shipping and tax) up to $7,500 per item, 2.35% above that, + $0.30 per order ($0.40 over $10) (as published, read 2026-11-08); lots of competing listings; you photograph, pack and ship | Anyone, and especially rare or expensive cards |
| TCGplayerFee source | A huge buyer base that already shops there for singles; Market Price as a reference; Pro and Direct programs for stores | 10.75% commission (capped at $75 per item) + a 2.5% + $0.30 transaction fee (seller Levels 1–4, as published, read 2026-11-08); you list against a catalogue entry and ship yourself | Stores and anyone selling many singles |
| WhatnotFee source | Live-stream selling to a lively audience; paid soon after delivery | 8% commission + 2.9% + $0.30 payment processing (as published, read 2026-11-08); you have to go live and hold the room | Sellers who enjoy streaming |
| Facebook groups, Discord servers and local meetups | No marketplace fee; buyers who know the game | No protection beyond what the payment app gives you; scams go both ways; meet in public or use a payment method with buyer and seller protection | Experienced sellers with a reputation in the group |
| Card shows and conventions | Vendors buy on the spot and collectors browse with cash; good for a binder of mid-value cards | Table fees if you sell yourself; vendors buy at buylist-style prices | A weekend's worth of selling in one place |
| TCGenius market (opening soon) | Member-to-member sales of single cards with the money held until delivery and real photos on every card; founding members are trying it now | Not open to everyone yet. Sign up free and it appears in your account the day it opens | Collectors selling singles to collectors, soon |
Fees were read on each site's own page on November 8, 2026; fees change, so check the linked page before you decide. Where a figure isn't published we say so instead of guessing. TCGenius is independent and not affiliated with eBay, TCGplayer or Whatnot; their names are used only to compare published facts.
What each fee comes to on a $100 card
| Where | Fee on a $100 sale, from the published rate |
|---|---|
| eBay | $13.25 + $0.30, and the 13.25% also applies to the shipping and tax the buyer pays |
| TCGplayer (Levels 1–4) | $10.75 + $2.50 + $0.30 = $13.55 |
| Whatnot | $8.00 + $2.90 + $0.30 = $11.20 |
| A buylist | No fee, but the offer itself is a share of market that isn't published; ask two shops |
Worked out from the rates above, read November 8, 2026. Arithmetic, not a quote; a store's buylist offer is set by the store.
How to get the most for them
- Find out what each card is worth first. Every Magic card on TCGenius has a page with its market price for each printing and a price chart, free, no account. Add the lot to the free collection tracker and it totals tonight's value for you. A market price is what the card has recently sold for, not what a buyer will offer.
- Split the pile into three: cards worth selling one at a time, cards worth more as a lot, and bulk. One valuable card deserves its own listing with photos; forty $1 cards sell as a lot or go to a buylist.
- Grade condition honestly. In Magic the usual grades are Near Mint, Lightly Played, Moderately Played, Heavily Played and Damaged; the set symbol and collector number decide the printing, and foils, showcase frames, extended art and Secret Lair versions each have their own price.
- Photograph the actual card, front and back, in daylight, with the corners and surface visible. Stock pictures are not allowed for used cards on eBay and buyers everywhere pay more when they can see what they're getting.
- Price against the market price for that exact printing and condition, then take the fee off before you decide whether it's worth it: the fee table above shows what each place takes on a $100 card.
- Check what's about to change the price. In Magic, Commander demand drives most singles, format bans move the competitive staples, and reprints are the big risk: a reprint in a new set or a Secret Lair can halve an older printing's price. Check the card's chart on TCGenius before you decide when to list.
- Ship like a card shop: penny sleeve, toploader or semi-rigid holder, bubble mailer, and tracking from about $20 up. Keep proof of postage.
What sells in Magic: The Gathering
Selling Magic cards near you
Wizards' store locator lists game stores near you: locator.wizards.com/. A shop buys at its buylist price, which is well under what the card sells for online, and in return you get cash or store credit today with no fees and no shipping. Bring the cards sorted with the valuable ones on top, know the market price of each from its TCGenius page, and ask whether credit pays a better rate than cash (it usually does).
Questions people ask
Where can I sell my Magic: The Gathering cards?
A local game store or an online buylist for cash or credit without fees; eBay for the most buyers; TCGplayer for selling many singles; Whatnot if you'll stream; Facebook groups, Discord servers and card shows for fee-free deals. Magic also has more store buylists than any other card game, each with a card-by-card price. Each option is compared above with its published fee.
Where can I sell Magic cards near me?
A local game store: most buy over the counter or against their buylist, in cash or store credit (credit is usually a better rate). Wizards' store locator lists stores near you. Card shows and local groups are the other in-person routes.
What is a buylist, and is it a good deal?
A buylist is a store's published price for cards it wants to buy. You get cash or credit now with no fees or shipping risk, and in return you take less than the card sells for; the share isn't published and differs by store, so compare two or three. For bulk and mid-value cards it's often the sensible choice; for a valuable card, selling it yourself usually nets more.
How do Card Kingdom's and Star City Games' buylists work?
Both publish the price they pay for each card they want. On Card Kingdom you search its sell list, add cards to a sell cart, ship them, and are paid by check, PayPal or store credit after grading; lower-condition cards are paid at a lower rate. Star City Games works the same way through a Sell List Request, which locks in the prices when you submit it, and it also has a Ship + Sell option for mailing in a collection without listing every card, for a processing fee. Each store's own selling page has its current terms; we don't quote their rates because they change.
Where do I sell Magic cards in Europe?
Cardmarket is the usual answer. You list cards at your own price and sell to buyers across Europe; Cardmarket charges a commission on each sale, shown in its fee table, and its Trustee Service holds the buyer's payment until the cards arrive on larger orders. Local game stores and card shows work the same as anywhere.
How do I know what my Magic cards are worth?
Look each card up on TCGenius: its page shows the market price (JustTCG, or TCGplayer where JustTCG has none) for the printing and a price chart, free. The set symbol and collector number tell you which printing you have, and foils and special frames are priced separately. Our guide walks through valuing a collection.
Should I worry about reprints?
Yes, more than in most games. A reprint in a new set, a Commander precon or a Secret Lair can halve an older printing's price. If a card you hold is a likely reprint and you were going to sell anyway, sooner is usually better than later.
Do Commander cards sell better than Standard cards?
Usually. Commander is the most played format and its staples sell steadily; a Standard card's demand ends when it rotates. Price each card by its own chart rather than by the format.
Can I sell Magic cards on TCGenius?
Soon. The TCGenius market, where members sell single cards to other members with the money held until delivery, is being tried by founding members now and opens to everyone shortly. Sign up free and it appears in your account the day it opens; until then the places above are the honest answer, and the value pages here are free.
Other games: Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Disney Lorcana. Also: eBay alternatives for selling cards · TCGplayer alternatives.
Last updated November 12, 2026. TCGenius is independent and not affiliated with the publishers or marketplaces named here. Spot something wrong? hello@tcgenius.gg.