CrystalCommerce alternatives for card shops
CrystalCommerce costs $99 a month (one plan) and takes 2.5% of online sales (0% on register and buylist sales), with a website included, as read on its page on November 15, 2026. Shops that look elsewhere usually compare BinderPOS (paused for new shops), ShadowPOS, SortSwift, or Shopify POS with a card app. The table shows each one's published price, cut and connections.
The alternatives at a glance
| Software | Price a month | Cut of online sales | Taking new shops | AI questions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BinderPOSRun by TCGplayer; built on Shopify | $100 a month (Binder) or $150 a month (Binder Pro), plus your own Shopify plan | 2% of website sales; 2.5% of sales through its TCGplayer link (US only) | Paused: new sign-ups are on a waiting list | None advertised |
| ShadowPOSStand-alone card shop software | $200 a month, everything included | 2% of public website sales; 2% of marketplace sales | Yes (book a demo) | None advertised |
| SortSwiftCard sorting machines plus shop software | Free plan, then $19 to $499 a month; the register comes with the $249 plan and up | 0% on marketplaces it syncs to; 2% on its own storefront orders | Yes | None advertised (rule-based repricing) |
| Shopify POSGeneral shop software, not made for cards | $39, $105 or $399 a month; POS Pro adds $89 a month per location (billed yearly) | None on Shopify Payments; 2% / 1% / 0.6% if you use another card processor | Yes | Sidekick, a general shop assistant |
For comparison, CrystalCommerce: $99 a month (one plan); 2.5% of online sales. Read on its own page on November 15, 2026. Every system has shops that love it. This page sets out the published facts so you can choose.
CrystalCommerce in full
CrystalCommerce
- Price a month
- $99 a month (one plan)
- Setup
- Shown as $0.99, with a $599 list price crossed out
- Cut of online sales
- 2.5% of online sales
- Cut of in-store sales
- 0% on register and buylist sales
- Card processing
- Not a card processor itself: connects to Authorize.net, Bombora and PayPal; rates not published
- Taking new shops
- Yes
- Connections
- eBay, Amazon, TCGplayer, CardTrader, Mana Pool, PriceCharting
- Shop website
- Yes, included (English only)
- AI or plain-English questions
- None advertised
- Support
- Live chat every day 9 AM to 5 PM Pacific; phone numbers listed
- Trial
- No trial; a 30-day money-back guarantee
Before you switch
- Export everything first
Inventory, customers, store credit and order history. Ask how each comes out before you need it. - Check the marketplace links you rely on
CrystalCommerce lists eBay, Amazon, TCGplayer, CardTrader and Mana Pool. Make sure the new system covers the ones that bring you sales. - Plan for your website address
Your website comes with CrystalCommerce. Decide early where it will live and keep the same address so Google doesn't lose you. - Move between big release weeks
Run both side by side for a week if you can, and never switch on a prerelease weekend.
A newer option: the TCGenius store system
We make one too, so judge this part for yourself. It's in trial with a small number of shops. It isn't a register yet: it's a buy counter, inventory and Ask Genny for your own numbers, running next to the system you already have. That means you can try it without switching anything.
TCGenius store system
- Price a month
- Free for a 2-month trial, no card needed. The price is announced before anything is charged, and the 5 founding shops keep their starting price for life
- Setup
- None. A founder sets it up with you
- Cut of online sales
- Not set yet; announced before anything is charged
- Cut of in-store sales
- Not set yet; announced before anything is charged
- Card processing
- No card payments yet: the register is being built
- Taking new shops
- A few trial shops at a time
- Connections
- Runs in a web browser next to the register you already use. Inventory, buys and sales download as spreadsheets any time
- Shop website
- A free store page on TCGenius with your games and events
- AI or plain-English questions
- Ask Genny: plain-English questions about your own stock, buys and sales, answered only from your records with the source shown
- Support
- A founder, directly
- Trial
- Yes: 2 months free, plus free Pro on the owner's account for those 2 months
Questions people ask
What does CrystalCommerce cost?
$99 a month (one plan), setup shown as $0.99, with a $599 list price crossed out, and 2.5% of online sales (0% on register and buylist sales), read on November 15, 2026.
Does CrystalCommerce have a free trial?
No trial; a 30-day money-back guarantee, per its pricing page read on November 15, 2026.
Does CrystalCommerce process card payments?
Not a card processor itself: connects to Authorize.net, Bombora and PayPal; rates not published
What are the alternatives to CrystalCommerce?
BinderPOS (paused for new shops when we read it), ShadowPOS, SortSwift and Shopify POS with a card app, compared in the table above.
Every system side by side: card shop POS systems compared.
Sources (each company's own pages, read November 15, 2026)
- CrystalCommerce: https://www.crystalcommerce.com/pricing/ and https://www.crystalcommerce.com/faq/
- BinderPOS: https://seller.tcgplayer.com/point-of-sale (binderpos.com and binderpos.com/pricing forward here)
- ShadowPOS: https://shadowpos.com/ and https://shadowpos.com/terms
- SortSwift: https://sortswift.com/ and https://sortswift.com/pricing
- Shopify POS: https://www.shopify.com/pos/pricing
Last updated November 15, 2026. TCGenius is independent and not affiliated with CrystalCommerce or any company on this page. Spot something wrong? hello@tcgenius.gg.