Card shop POS systems compared
The main point-of-sale systems used by trading card shops are BinderPOS, CrystalCommerce, ShadowPOS, SortSwift, Shopify POS. They differ most on four things: the monthly price, the cut they take of online and marketplace sales, whether they connect to TCGplayer, and whether they're taking new shops today. Every figure below was read on that company's own page on November 15, 2026. Where something isn't published, we say so instead of guessing.
At a glance
| Software | Price a month | Cut of online sales | Taking new shops | AI questions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BinderPOSRun by TCGplayer; built on Shopify | $100 a month (Binder) or $150 a month (Binder Pro), plus your own Shopify plan | 2% of website sales; 2.5% of sales through its TCGplayer link (US only) | Paused: new sign-ups are on a waiting list | None advertised |
| CrystalCommerceLong-running card shop website and register | $99 a month (one plan) | 2.5% of online sales | Yes | None advertised |
| ShadowPOSStand-alone card shop software | $200 a month, everything included | 2% of public website sales; 2% of marketplace sales | Yes (book a demo) | None advertised |
| SortSwiftCard sorting machines plus shop software | Free plan, then $19 to $499 a month; the register comes with the $249 plan and up | 0% on marketplaces it syncs to; 2% on its own storefront orders | Yes | None advertised (rule-based repricing) |
| Shopify POSGeneral shop software, not made for cards | $39, $105 or $399 a month; POS Pro adds $89 a month per location (billed yearly) | None on Shopify Payments; 2% / 1% / 0.6% if you use another card processor | Yes | Sidekick, a general shop assistant |
Prices change. Check each company's page before you decide. TCGenius makes a store system too, so we put ours last and kept it to what's true today.
Every detail, one system at a time
BinderPOS
- Price a month
- $100 a month (Binder) or $150 a month (Binder Pro), plus your own Shopify plan
- Setup
- Not published
- Cut of online sales
- 2% of website sales; 2.5% of sales through its TCGplayer link (US only)
- Cut of in-store sales
- Not published
- Card processing
- Not published
- Taking new shops
- Paused: new sign-ups are on a waiting list
- Connections
- TCGplayer (US only), eBay (Binder Pro); needs Shopify
- Shop website
- Yes, through Shopify
- AI or plain-English questions
- None advertised
- Support
- Tickets any time, Zoom training; hours not published
- Trial
- Not published
CrystalCommerce
- Price a month
- $99 a month (one plan)
- Setup
- Shown as $0.99, with a $599 list price crossed out
- Cut of online sales
- 2.5% of online sales
- Cut of in-store sales
- 0% on register and buylist sales
- Card processing
- Not a card processor itself: connects to Authorize.net, Bombora and PayPal; rates not published
- Taking new shops
- Yes
- Connections
- eBay, Amazon, TCGplayer, CardTrader, Mana Pool, PriceCharting
- Shop website
- Yes, included (English only)
- AI or plain-English questions
- None advertised
- Support
- Live chat every day 9 AM to 5 PM Pacific; phone numbers listed
- Trial
- No trial; a 30-day money-back guarantee
ShadowPOS
- Price a month
- $200 a month, everything included
- Setup
- Not published
- Cut of online sales
- 2% of public website sales; 2% of marketplace sales
- Cut of in-store sales
- No in-store fee (card processing aside)
- Card processing
- From 2.6% + 15¢, in person and online
- Taking new shops
- Yes (book a demo)
- Connections
- CardTrader, Mana Pool, Shippo, CardCastle, PriceCharting
- Shop website
- Yes, included
- AI or plain-English questions
- None advertised
- Support
- Email and chat Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Eastern
- Trial
- Not published
SortSwift
- Price a month
- Free plan, then $19 to $499 a month; the register comes with the $249 plan and up
- Setup
- No setup fee
- Cut of online sales
- 0% on marketplaces it syncs to; 2% on its own storefront orders
- Cut of in-store sales
- 0%
- Card processing
- Stripe at cost: 2.7% + 5¢ in person, 2.9% + 30¢ online
- Taking new shops
- Yes
- Connections
- Shopify, eBay, TCGplayer (in testing), CardTrader, Mana Pool, Square, WooCommerce, Walmart and more
- Shop website
- A storefront exists; which plans include it isn't stated
- AI or plain-English questions
- None advertised (rule-based repricing)
- Support
- Help centre, Discord, book a call; hours not published
- Trial
- Free plan, no card needed
Shopify POS
- Price a month
- $39, $105 or $399 a month; POS Pro adds $89 a month per location (billed yearly)
- Setup
- Not published
- Cut of online sales
- None on Shopify Payments; 2% / 1% / 0.6% if you use another card processor
- Cut of in-store sales
- None beyond card processing
- Card processing
- In person 2.6% + 10¢ (Basic), 2.5% + 10¢ (Grow), 2.4% + 10¢ (Advanced)
- Taking new shops
- Yes
- Connections
- Card shop apps add the card parts (BinderPOS is one)
- Shop website
- Yes
- AI or plain-English questions
- Sidekick, a general shop assistant
- Support
- Not published
- Trial
- 3 days free, then 3 months for $1 a month
TCGenius store system
- Price a month
- Free for a 2-month trial, no card needed. The price is announced before anything is charged, and the 5 founding shops keep their starting price for life
- Setup
- None. A founder sets it up with you
- Cut of online sales
- Not set yet; announced before anything is charged
- Cut of in-store sales
- Not set yet; announced before anything is charged
- Card processing
- No card payments yet: the register is being built
- Taking new shops
- A few trial shops at a time
- Connections
- Runs in a web browser next to the register you already use. Inventory, buys and sales download as spreadsheets any time
- Shop website
- A free store page on TCGenius with your games and events
- AI or plain-English questions
- Ask Genny: plain-English questions about your own stock, buys and sales, answered only from your records with the source shown
- Support
- A founder, directly
- Trial
- Yes: 2 months free, plus free Pro on the owner's account for those 2 months
Nine questions to ask before you sign
- Does it connect to TCGplayer, and how?
A link to the TCGplayer marketplace (listing and orders) is the thing many shops can't live without, and not every system has one. - What cut does it take, and of which sales?
Online sales, marketplace sales and in-store sales are often charged differently. Add the monthly fee to the cut on a normal month's sales. - Who processes the cards, and at what rate?
Some systems process cards themselves, some pass a processor's rate through, some leave it to you. - Is it open to new shops today?
Some have waiting lists. Ask how long setup takes. - Can you try it before you pay?
A free plan, a trial, a money-back guarantee or a demo only: these are very different. - Can you take your data with you?
Ask for a spreadsheet of inventory, buys and sales, and try the export before you commit. - Does stock stay right when a card sells in two places?
Ask how often it syncs, and what happens when the same card sells online and at the counter in the same minute. - How fast is buying a collection?
Time a 100-card buy in the demo. The buy counter is where a shop's day goes. - When can you reach a person?
Prerelease weekends and evenings are when things break. Check the support hours against your own.
Questions people ask
What POS systems do trading card shops use?
The card-specific ones are BinderPOS (run by TCGplayer, built on Shopify), CrystalCommerce, ShadowPOS and SortSwift. Many shops also use general systems such as Shopify POS or Square with a card app added. Prices and cuts for each are in the table, read on each company's own page on November 15, 2026.
Which card shop POS connects to TCGplayer?
On their own pages: BinderPOS has a TCGplayer link (US only, 2.5% of those sales) and CrystalCommerce lists TCGplayer among its connections. SortSwift lists a TCGplayer link as in testing. ShadowPOS doesn't list one.
Which card shop POS is cheapest?
It depends on your sales. Add the monthly fee to the cut each takes of your online and marketplace sales, then compare card processing rates on your normal month. The table has every published figure.
Is BinderPOS taking new shops?
Its page said new sign-ups were paused, with a waiting list, when we read it on November 15, 2026.
Does any card shop POS have AI?
None of the card shop systems in this table advertised AI questions about a shop's own numbers when we read their pages. Shopify offers Sidekick, a general shop assistant. The TCGenius store system's Ask Genny answers questions about a shop's own stock, buys and sales, and it is in trial.
Sources (each company's own pages, read November 15, 2026)
- BinderPOS: https://seller.tcgplayer.com/point-of-sale (binderpos.com and binderpos.com/pricing forward here)
- CrystalCommerce: https://www.crystalcommerce.com/pricing/ and https://www.crystalcommerce.com/faq/
- ShadowPOS: https://shadowpos.com/ and https://shadowpos.com/terms
- SortSwift: https://sortswift.com/ and https://sortswift.com/pricing
- Shopify POS: https://www.shopify.com/pos/pricing
Last updated November 15, 2026. TCGenius is independent and not affiliated with any company on this page. Spot something wrong or out of date? hello@tcgenius.gg and we'll fix it.