Guide
Is it worth grading a card? The sum to do before you pay PSA, CGC or TAG
Grading pays only when the graded price, minus the fee and shipping, beats what the card sells for raw. Here is the sum, today's fees, a worked example, and the chance of a 10 you need to break even.
You pulled a card that looks perfect, and the first thing everybody tells you is "get that graded". Sometimes that is right. Often the fee and the shipping eat the whole gain, and you end up with less than you would have got by selling the card as it was. The difference is one small sum.
The sum
Grading is worth it when:
graded price, minus the grading fee, minus shipping, is more than the raw price.
That is all. The raw price is what the card sells for ungraded today. The graded price is what the same card sells for in a slab at the grade it actually gets. You do not know the grade in advance, so you run the sum twice: once for a 10 and once for a 9.
What grading costs today
| Company | Service | Fee per card | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSA | Value | $39.99 | insured up to $500 |
| PSA | Standard | $59.99 | insured up to $1,000 |
| PSA | Priority | $79.99 | insured up to $1,500 |
| CGC Cards | Economy | $20.00 | cards worth up to $1,000 |
| TAG | Base | $39.95 | 5-card minimum |
Read from each company's own price page on November 12, 2026. Fees change: check the company's page before you send cards.
Those are per-card fees for each company's lower-priced services. Shipping to the grader and back, with insurance, comes on top, and so do the fees of wherever you sell the slab afterwards.
A worked example
Say a card sells for $40 raw. In a slab it sells for $150 as a 10 and $60 as a 9. The fee is $20 and shipping works out at $5 a card. These numbers are made up to show the sum.
| If it comes back a 10 | If it comes back a 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Graded price | $150 | $60 |
| Minus fee and shipping | $25 | $25 |
| Minus what it sells for raw | $40 | $40 |
| What grading added | $85 | minus $5 |
So this card is worth grading only if it has a real chance at a 10. A 9 loses you five dollars and the wait.
The chance of a 10 you need
Put those two outcomes together and you get a break-even point: the chance of a 10 at which grading stops losing money. In the example it is about 6%. If you believe the card gets a 10 more often than about one time in eighteen, the sum is on your side.
Two warnings about that figure. It assumes a card that misses a 10 comes back a 9, and a lower grade does worse, so treat it as the least you need. And nobody can promise a grade: it is arithmetic on today's prices, not a forecast.
Three quick rules
- If the raw price is below the grading fee, grading rarely pays, unless the card means something to you.
- The gap between a 9 and a 10 is where the money is. If a 9 sells for about the raw price, you are betting everything on a 10.
- Condition decides the grade before the grader does. Centering, corners, edges and surface. Look at the card under a bright light, front and back, before you spend anything.
Do the sum with real prices
Is it worth grading? does this for any card. Pick the card or type its prices, choose a grading fee, add your shipping, and it shows what grading adds at a 10 and at a 9 and the break-even chance of a 10.
A note on the graded prices we show: a graded price appears on TCGenius only when there are recorded sales of that exact slab. We never estimate one by multiplying the raw price. When there are no recent sales, the page shows nothing and you type the price yourself.
For Pokémon cards, the grading scanner goes one step further: photograph the card and it gives a likely grade range, with the centering measured, next to today's raw price and grading fees.
Not grading is a fine answer
Most cards should stay raw. A raw card sells today, costs nothing to hold and can still be graded later if its price climbs. Grade the few cards where the sum is clearly on your side, and sell or keep the rest as they are.