More
Log inCreate free accountJoin freeBuild a deck

Guide

EDH power level vs Commander brackets: how to rate your deck honestly

The 1 to 10 power level is a table habit with no official scale. Commander brackets are Wizards' system. Here is what each one measures, how we count both, and what to say before the game starts.

By TCGenius3 min read

"It's about a 7." Every Commander player has heard it, and every Commander player has then lost on turn four to a deck that was not a 7. The trouble is not that people lie. It is that two different things get called "power level", and only one of them has rules.

Two different measures

Commander brackets are Wizards of the Coast's system. There are five: Exhibition (1), Core (2), Upgraded (3), Optimized (4) and cEDH (5).

The 1 to 10 power level is a habit, not a rule. There is no official scale, and two honest players can disagree by a point about the same list.

Use both. The bracket tells the table what kind of game you came for. The number tells them how hard your deck pushes inside it.

What a bracket actually checks

The one part of the bracket system with a published count is the Game Changers list: a list of especially powerful cards that Wizards keeps and updates.

BracketGame Changers allowed
1 (Exhibition) and 2 (Core)None
3 (Upgraded)Up to three
4 (Optimized) and 5 (cEDH)Any number

That count is not the whole bracket. Wizards also names fast two-card combos, extra turns and mass land destruction as things a bracket depends on, without publishing a number for them. So a deck with no Game Changers can still play like a Bracket 4 deck, and only your table can weigh that.

The Commander bracket calculator counts the Game Changers in your list, shows each one, and lists the extra-turn and land-destruction cards it finds so you can judge them yourself.

How we work out the 1 to 10 number

Because no official scale exists, ours shows its working. The EDH power level calculator counts things in your list and nothing else. No AI reads the deck.

What is countedPoints
Every deck starts at2.5
How well the deck is built (its Commander deck grade out of 100)up to 2.0
Game Changers0.5 each, up to 2.0
Tutors (cards that search your library for a non-land card)0.25 each, up to 1.0
Fast mana (non-land mana sources that cost 0 or 1)0.2 each, up to 1.0
Speed (average mana value of your non-land cards)from -0.5 to +0.75
Extra turns, land destruction0.25 each when present

Every card that counted is listed under the number, so you can check it and disagree with it.

What the number means

LevelNameWhat to expect
9 to 10cEDH territoryBuilt to win as fast as possible, with wins in the first few turns
7.5 to 8.9High powerA tuned deck with strong cards, tutors and fast mana
6 to 7.4FocusedAn upgraded deck with a clear plan and some powerful cards
4 to 5.9CasualAbout the level of a preconstructed deck. Most Commander decks sit here
1 to 3.9Low powerA theme deck, or one still missing the lands, ramp or card draw it needs

What to say before the game

A number alone starts arguments. Thirty seconds of specifics ends them. Before you shuffle, tell the table four things:

  1. Your bracket, and how many Game Changers you play.
  2. Your number, and that it is an estimate.
  3. How the deck wins, and the earliest turn it can realistically do it.
  4. Anything people hate being surprised by: extra turns, land destruction, a two-card combo.

If your deck is the odd one out, swap it before the game rather than after turn four.

Rate your own deck

Paste your list into the EDH power level calculator. Lists copied from Moxfield, Archidekt, MTG Arena or Magic Online work as they are. It is free, nothing is saved and you do not need an account. If you are still building, the Magic deck builder checks a Commander deck against the format's rules and ban list as you go.

Do it with your own cards

Build a Magic deck
The free Magic deck builder checks your deck against its format's rules and ban list, grades it and deals test hands.
Open the Magic deck builder

Keep reading

The weekly meta report, by email every FridayWhich decks rose and fell in Pokémon and One Piece top 8s, what the winning lists changed, and the week's ban list and set news. One email a week; every one has an unsubscribe link.
We use your email only for this. See the Privacy Policy.
Share: XRedditFacebook