More
Log inCreate free accountJoin freeBuild a deck
Magic cards › Foundations
Painful Quandary (Foundations)

Painful Quandary 3BB

$1.39–$4.90Market price (JustTCG, or TCGplayer via Scryfall where JustTCG has none) by printingSee listings

Enchantment

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.

Mana value 5 · Color identity B · Illustrated by David Palumbo

First printed October 1, 2010 in Scars of Mirrodin · 7 printings.

Printings and prices

SetNumberRarityReleasedPriceFoil
Foundations179Rare2024-11-15$1.84$2.07
Foundations Promos Prerelease promo, Foil only179sRare2024-11-15–$1.99
The Brothers' War Promos Prerelease promo, Foil only111sRare2022-11-18–$3.03
The Brothers' War111Rare2022-11-18$1.39$2.61
The Brothers' War Extended art331Rare2022-11-18$4.90$7.00
The Brothers' War Promos Promo Pack111pRare2022-11-18$2.83$2.52
Scars of Mirrodin73Rare2010-10-01$3.13$21.50

Market prices (JustTCG, or TCGplayer via Scryfall where JustTCG has none) (last checked Nov 16, 2026). A guide, not a quote.

Official rulings

Buy this card: TCGplayer · eBay · Cardmarket (EU)
We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.

Price history & alerts

Build with this card
The free Magic deck builder checks every deck against its format's rules and ban list, and Genny can build one around Painful Quandary.
Open the Magic deck builder

Card data and card images from Scryfall (Oracle text and rulings are Wizards of the Coast's). Prices are market prices from JustTCG, or TCGplayer's via Scryfall where JustTCG has none.

TCGenius is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Not approved or endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.

Share: XRedditFacebook